Home How To Prepare Your Home Made Macaroni byHubpages •September 29, 2015 0 INGREDIENTS 2 2⁄3cups elbow macaroni 1 1⁄3tablespoons butter 8 -10 2⁄3slices American cheese 1⁄3cup evaporated milk 1 1⁄3to taste salt and pepper DIRECTIONS 1. Boil 4 cups of salted water and add the macaroni; cook 8 minutes, or until done; Drain macaroni and set aside. 2. In a medium saucepan, melt butter over LOW heat. 3. Add cheese slices, one by one, until all are melted through, and cheese is smooth. 4. Stir in the canned milk, more or less to your desired consistency. 5. Add drained macaroni to cheese mixture; add salt and pepper to taste, and mix well until coated. Serve immediately. Facebook Twitter